Why Did The United States Join The North American Free Trade Agreement

In 2008, Canadian exports to the United States and Mexico totaled $381.3 billion, while imports totaled $245.1 billion. [59] According to a 2004 article by University of Toronto economist Daniel Trefler, NAFTA brought significant net benefits to Canada in 2003, with long-term productivity increasing by up to 15% in industries that experienced the largest tariff reductions. [60] Although the shrinking of low-productivity farms has reduced employment (up to 12% of existing jobs), these job losses have lasted less than a decade; Overall, unemployment in Canada has declined since the legislation was passed. Commenting on this compromise, Trefler said the crucial issue of trade policy is “understanding how freer trade can be implemented in an industrialized economy in a way that recognizes both the long-term gains and short-term adjustment costs of workers and others.” [61] According to a 2018 Sierra Club report, Canada`s commitments under NAFTA and the Paris Agreement are at odds with each other. The Paris commitments were voluntary and the NAFTA commitments were mandatory. [65] U.S. Department of Commerce. EC internal market, free movement of goods, free movement of goods, free movement of persons “New updates of 2005 data.” Available from www.census.gov/foreign-trade/statistics/. Retrieved 17 April 2006. Moreover, many economists argue that recent U.S. production problems have little to do with NAFTA, arguing that domestic production was under pressure decades before the treaty. A 2016 study published by David Autor, David Dorn and Gordon Hanson [PDF] found that competition with China has had a much greater negative impact on U.S.

employment since 2001, when China joined the WTO. Hanson, an economist and trade expert at the University of California, San Diego (UCSD), says the biggest decline in manufacturing jobs — seventeen to eleven million between 2000 and 2010 — is largely due to trade with China and underlying technological changes. “China tops the list in terms of the impact on employment that we`ve seen since 2000, with technology coming in second and NAFTA much less important,” he says. President Donald Trump promised during the election campaign to repeal NAFTA and other trade agreements that he considered unfair to the United States. On August 27, 2018, he announced a new trade agreement with Mexico to replace him. The U.S.-Mexico trade agreement, as it was called, would maintain duty-free access for agricultural products on both sides of the border and remove non-tariff barriers to trade, while further promoting agricultural trade between Mexico and the United States and effectively replacing NAFTA. On the other hand, Canada has long sold 99% or more of its total oil exports to the United States: it did so even before the two countries concluded a free trade agreement in 1988. In other words, NAFTA does not appear to have done much to open up the U.S. market to Canadian crude. It was already wide open – Canadians were just producing more. A 2015 study found that Mexico`s welfare increased by 1.31 percent due to NAFTA tariff cuts and Mexico`s intra-bloc trade increased by 118 percent.

[63] Inequality and poverty have decreased in the regions of Mexico most affected by globalization. [75] Studies from 2013 and 2015 showed that Mexican smallholder farmers benefited more from NAFTA than large farmers. [76] [77] Although President Donald Trump warned Canada on September 1 that he would exclude them from a new trade deal if Canada did not comply with his demands, it is not clear that the Trump administration has the power to do so without congressional approval. [145]:34–6[146][147][148] According to Congressional Research Service (CRS) reports, one published in 2017 and the other on July 26, 2018, it is likely that Congressional approval of substantial NAFTA changes would have to be obtained from President Trump before the changes can be implemented. [145]:34-6[149] NAFTA has long been a political objective. In 2008, then-presidential candidate Barack Obama responded to widespread trade skepticism among the Democratic base by promising to renegotiate NAFTA to include stricter labor and environmental standards. .

Comments are closed.